Fourth Circuit Lets Maryland Enforce Kalshi Betting Laws

Fourth Circuit Lets Maryland Enforce Kalshi Betting Laws

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit has left Maryland free to enforce its sports-wagering laws against Kalshi while litigation continues, adding another adverse appellate result for the prediction-market operator. In its November 17 opinion, the court affirmed a federal district judge’s refusal to grant Kalshi a preliminary injunction against state regulators. The ruling preserves Maryland’s enforcement authority for now, but it is not a final merits judgment resolving every legal question in the case.

The 2-1 result is legally unusual because the two judges forming the majority did not agree on a single rationale. Judge Roger Gregory concluded that even assuming Kalshi’s sports contracts qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, federal law does not clearly eliminate Maryland’s traditional authority over gambling. Judge Stephanie Thacker instead concluded that the contracts are not swaps at all and therefore fall outside the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. Both approaches defeat Kalshi’s request for federal protection from Maryland, but they create different legal paths to the same outcome.

Appeals Courts Remain Split Over Kalshi

The Fourth Circuit decision follows two other appellate losses for Kalshi. The Ninth Circuit ruled on August 28 that its sports-event contracts were unlikely to qualify as swaps under the CEA, allowing Nevada gaming regulation to apply. The Sixth Circuit reached a similar result on September 25 in cases involving Ohio and Tennessee, holding that the contracts were not swaps and that the CEA did not preempt the states’ gambling laws. Three appellate courts have now produced outcomes allowing state enforcement against Kalshi’s sports markets.

The Third Circuit reached the opposite conclusion on April 6. In Flaherty v. KalshiEX, it held that Kalshi’s sports-event contracts qualify as swaps traded on a CFTC-licensed designated contract market and that the CFTC therefore has exclusive jurisdiction over them. That direct disagreement over both the definition of a swap and federal preemption has created a genuine circuit split.

The dispute has already created operational conflicts for Kalshi. Earlier this year, the company found itself caught between a Michigan order restricting sports markets and a federal regulatory position supporting continued contract execution, a tension reflected in the Michigan sports-betting dispute. The Fourth Circuit ruling adds Maryland to the jurisdictions where state requirements can currently constrain the same federally registered exchange.

That legal uncertainty is developing as Kalshi expands far beyond its original event-contract business. The company has reportedly pursued $1 billion in new financing at a $40 billion valuation, while the CFTC has also increased its focus on prediction-market integrity through guidance addressing manipulation risks in specialized event contracts. The regulatory dispute therefore affects an increasingly large derivatives platform rather than a niche experimental market.

Supreme Court Review Is Already Pending

The federal-state conflict has also moved beyond the appellate courts. New Jersey filed a petition with the U.S. Supreme Court on September 2 asking the justices to review the Third Circuit decision that favored Kalshi. Supreme Court docket No. 26-299 shows Kalshi’s response deadline has been extended to December 7. The Supreme Court has not agreed to hear the case, but a certiorari petition addressing the circuit split is already pending.

The regulatory branches remain divided as well. The CFTC currently states that federally regulated prediction markets may operate across all 50 states, while nine Democratic senators recently urged the agency to reverse its position against state and tribal geofencing, citing court orders restricting prediction contracts in several jurisdictions. The conflict now involves not only competing appellate interpretations of the Commodity Exchange Act, but also competing views of how federal derivatives oversight should coexist with state gambling authority.

The Fourth Circuit ruling does not resolve that national question. Instead, it reinforces the fragmentation: Maryland can enforce its rules, the Third Circuit still protects Kalshi from New Jersey regulation, and multiple other appellate decisions favor state authority through different legal reasoning. Until the Supreme Court intervenes or Congress clarifies the Commodity Exchange Act, sports prediction markets can remain federally regulated products whose availability is nevertheless shaped by the state in which a customer is located.

Follow Us

Ads

Main Title

Sub Title

It is a long established fact that a reader will be distracted by the readable

Ads
banner 900px x 170px