U.S. senators pressed Commodity Futures Trading Commission nominees Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick on prediction markets during their November 17 confirmation hearing, placing sports event contracts, state authority and public-interest safeguards at the center of the discussion. The Senate Agriculture Committee’s official hearing record confirms both nominations remain before the committee. The hearing exposed continuing disagreement over where federally regulated derivatives end and state-regulated gambling begins.
Rowland offered the more explicit caution, saying the CFTC should “think long and hard” about balancing public interest against the economic usefulness of event contracts. He also said he was sympathetic to concerns raised by states and tribal governments. Anonick declined to characterize an NFL outcome contract definitively as sports betting and said he would consider stakeholder views and follow controlling court decisions. Neither nominee endorsed an unrestricted expansion of prediction markets or called for their wholesale prohibition. Non-crypto industry publication SBC Americas also reported that both avoided definitive answers on the sports-contract jurisdiction dispute.
Two CFTC Proposals Address Different Questions
The regulatory backdrop includes two separate proposals. In June, the CFTC proposed amendments to Regulation 40.11 establishing factors for deciding when event contracts involving statutorily enumerated activities are contrary to the public interest. The proposal covers unlawful activity, terrorism, assassination, war and gaming, with specific tests for sports contracts. It is a proposed public-interest review framework, not a blanket final ban on every contract falling into those categories.
A separate October rulemaking would explicitly further define “swap” to include event contracts tied to sports, politics, cultural events and weather. That proposal responds partly to conflicting federal appellate decisions about whether sports contracts fit the Commodity Exchange Act’s swap definition. Classification as a swap and a determination that a particular contract is contrary to the public interest are separate legal questions.
Market-integrity concerns are developing alongside the jurisdiction debate. The CFTC has already warned that event contracts tied to what specific individuals say or do can carry heightened manipulation risk, while federal enforcement has also focused on misuse of confidential information. A separate Pentagon policy now restricts prediction-market trading based on nonpublic military information. The agency’s expanding role therefore involves surveillance and insider-trading controls as well as deciding which contracts fall within federal jurisdiction.
States Continue to Challenge Federal Preemption
The larger legal conflict remains unresolved. As of November 13, the CFTC had sued 12 states, most recently Louisiana, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state attempts to regulate federally registered prediction-market exchanges. States have taken the opposite position in cases involving sports contracts, arguing that products economically equivalent to wagering remain subject to local gambling laws. Federal and state authorities are therefore asserting overlapping control over the same activity.
The dispute has already produced conflicting operational requirements. In Michigan, Kalshi faced a state order restricting sports markets while the CFTC directed the exchange to honor open contracts. Utah escalated the conflict further by filing criminal charges against Kalshi and its co-founders. Those cases demonstrate that the jurisdictional disagreement already affects contract execution and legal exposure rather than remaining an abstract policy debate.
The CFTC inspector general recently identified prediction-market jurisdiction as a major management challenge for fiscal 2027, citing conflicting appellate decisions and a pending Supreme Court petition. Rowland and Anonick would join Chairman Michael Selig if confirmed, expanding a commission that has operated with only one member while its prediction-market responsibilities have grown. The immediate uncertainty is not whether event contracts will remain under scrutiny, but which combination of CFTC rules, federal court decisions and state authority will ultimately govern them.

