The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank’s challenge over access to a Federal Reserve master account on November 16, closing the appellate path in the Wyoming bank’s long-running case against the Federal Reserve Board and Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. The denial leaves the Tenth Circuit’s ruling intact but does not constitute a Supreme Court endorsement of its reasoning. The Supreme Court docket records the petition as denied without an accompanying opinion.
Custodia applied for a master account in October 2020 after receiving its Wyoming special purpose depository institution charter. The Kansas City Fed told the bank in January 2021 that it was legally eligible and that there were “no showstoppers,” according to the appellate record, but the Federal Reserve subsequently introduced a tiered account-access framework in August 2022. Non-federally insured institutions such as Custodia fall under Tier 3, the framework’s highest-scrutiny category.
Appeals Court Upheld Federal Reserve Discretion
The Kansas City Fed ultimately denied Custodia’s master-account request, while the Federal Reserve Board separately rejected its application for Fed membership in January 2023. The Board cited safety-and-soundness concerns surrounding Custodia’s proposed crypto activities and said its risk-management framework was insufficient to address risks including money laundering and terrorist financing. Those membership concerns were separate from, although closely connected to, the Kansas City Fed’s master-account decision.
After a Wyoming federal district court rejected Custodia’s claims, a divided Tenth Circuit panel affirmed the judgment on October 31, 2025. The majority held that Reserve Banks retain discretion to reject master-account applications from otherwise eligible institutions and concluded that Custodia was not “statutorily and automatically entitled” to an account. Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented, arguing that the Monetary Control Act’s requirement that Fed services “shall be available” to nonmember depository institutions limited that discretion. The central legal disagreement was eligibility versus entitlement: being legally eligible to apply does not, under the majority’s interpretation, compel approval.
The full Tenth Circuit denied rehearing in March 2026, and Custodia filed its Supreme Court petition on July 10. The high court’s refusal to take the case means the panel decision continues to govern Custodia’s dispute and carries precedential weight within the Tenth Circuit. It does not independently establish a nationwide Supreme Court rule governing every Reserve Bank master-account application.
Limited Fed Access Remains a Separate Path
The regulatory landscape has nevertheless changed since Custodia first applied. In March, the Kansas City Fed approved Kraken Financial, another Wyoming SPDI, for a one-year limited-purpose account. Kraken can access only Fedwire Funds Service, cannot obtain intraday or discount-window credit, faces a closing-balance cap and receives no interest on its Fed balance. Kraken’s arrangement demonstrates that restricted direct access can be granted without providing the full functionality associated with a conventional master account.
That account should not be confused with the Federal Reserve’s broader proposed “Payment Account.” The Board formally proposed that framework in May 2026 for legally eligible institutions focused on clearing and settlement, with no intraday credit, no discount-window access and no interest on balances. As recently as November, Federal Reserve officials were still discussing the proposal with industry participants. The Payment Account therefore remained under policy development rather than functioning as an established alternative available automatically to crypto-focused banks.
The dispute sits alongside a wider restructuring of crypto companies’ relationships with federal financial regulators. Firms including Ripple have obtained national trust-bank charters, while banking groups have pushed regulators to scrutinize crypto-linked charter applications. Coinbase, Circle and Ripple have also moved further into federally supervised digital-asset custody. Those OCC charters and Federal Reserve payment access are legally distinct gateways, however, and obtaining one does not automatically provide the other.
For Custodia, the November 16 order leaves its original master-account challenge unsuccessful after more than six years from application to final appellate disposition. For other eligible institutions, Reserve Bank access remains governed by risk-based review while the Fed considers a narrower payment-account framework. The immediate legal result is therefore narrower than a blanket prohibition on crypto banks: Custodia could not compel the Kansas City Fed to grant the full account it sought.

